You can write from any experience, any viewpoint, use any language or emotion that you see fit. Worship song writing is very different.
While there is no standard to measure your lyrics against in secular music (although it is clear that both good and poor lyrics are written), in worship song writing we HAVE to measure our songs lyrically against one single plumb line that exists. The Bible.
While experience, emotion and world view can clearly influence our lyric writing, they hold very little real value in the scope of worship songwriting if the lyrics are not theologically sound and watertight, as measured against Truth.
Biblical Truth trumps experience/emotion/view point EVERY TIME
Our congregations theology is based more on the songs we sing than the preaches we hear. Your responsibility as a worship song writer is great. Measure your songs constantly against Truth. Find a church leader to check the lyrics for you.
Please hear me clearly – there is a place for experience/emotion/view point – as long as they are aligned with the Bible, and used carefully. A vague song about ‘feelings’ will dissolve into insignificance when stood next to a theologically pure exaltation, that builds faith, teaches Truth, reflects the nature God, praises his works or remembers the redeeming work of the cross.
John 4 v24 – “God is spirit, and his worshippers must worship in the Spirit and in truth” (italics mine)